Accepted WAN/LAN auto-sensing
Background:
There is a typical network topology:
Some users might notice that, once the internet service fails, they are no longer able to access the NAS server from the local network.
The cause of this Phenomenon:
When internet service went down and cable modem failed to provide IP address for Main Deco, both Ethernet ports on the main Deco would work as WAN ports to detect internet connection. NAS would no longer obtain an IP address from Deco.
Why do we use WAN/LAN auto-sensing on Deco?
For the Deco Mesh system, normally it would have more than 2 units and each unit has at least 2 Ethernet ports; It would be time-consuming and confusing to find out which port should be connected to the ISP modem. And supposing that the WAN port is fixed, once this port is broken, the whole Mesh kit would be useless.
Recommended Solutions:
- Given that the issue arises only when the ISP modem failed to assign IP address for the main Deco, once the cable modem recovered, the problem should be resolved. It is suggested to contact the ISP to restore the modem connection as a priority.
- The current workaround would be connecting the wired servers to the satellite Deco units, instead of the main one.
- And We have also implemented enhancements on certain models, ensuring that the WAN port remains constant as long as the physical Ethernet connection between the modem and main Deco is unchanged, even when there is no internet service from the modem.
- Moreover, It is also planned to support manually fixing a specific Ethernet port as WAN post on the Deco APP later. (Some models already support this feature, such as Deco X80-5G/Deco X20-4G)
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi, pretty sure it's in all Decos, I have a mix of x20s x50s, and E4, and I have the same problem.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
"Never buying tp-link devices ever again."
This is where I am at as well. I have completely lost all incentive to purchase from TP-Link ever again because of this crazy implementation. Our next home network (which I am currently planning) will NOT contain any TP-Link based hardware.
The fact that developers think this is a feature rather than a major bug just shows how out-of-touch they are with their user base. The truth is most users that run into this issue will (1) not know enough to figure out what's going on and (2) not bother to sign up for this forum to complain about it. It doesn't mean this problem isn't affecting a massive amount of users, it just means that few users will actually have their frustrations heard. And what happens when a product doesn't work and a user can't figure it out? Either they return the product or they throw it away and buy a different brand. TP-Link's boneheaded development decision is marketing against its own interests.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
I actually "side-graded" my whole network from a unifi-based one, because I decided that all the granularity and power user stuff was not really needed for home use and the Deco hardware had been top-notch until this point.
The fact that the lack of internet crippled my entire network for something that could be very easily fixed is just mind boggling to me. "Oh we dont have a dedicated WAN port so users have an easier time connecting their modem into whatever port they please"... ok, that's valid, how about we just toggle that feature off and have the WAN port always be port 1?
On top of that, my internet connection got reestablished after 4 days and when it came back, all the deco stations were freaking out and coming in and out of service. The main deco would come online but the secondary ones (all with ethernet backhaul) would stay offline and viceversa. Eventually I had to remove all of them except the main one, and then re-add one by one manually... Again, i'm pretty sure this was due to the auto-sense trying to figure out which cable had internet access and whatnot.
Considering switching to eero, they have clear WAN/LAN ports so i'm pretty sure this is not gonna be an issue there, but I still need to properly investigate to avoid similar issues.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Liebes TP-Link Team, ich bitte um Info bis wann das Problem gelöst ist? Wenn es vor dem 28.09.2022 gelöst ist kann ich die Geräte behalten wenn nicht werde ich sie zurückschicken müssen, denn nurt weil gerade das Internet aufällt kann ja nicht das interne Netzwerk mit ausfallen....
LG Thomas
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
I just came across this thread, my LAN port is down again, second time in a month. What is the resolution to getting the LAN port working again? all my wired devices are down, again.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
what hardware are you thinking of switching to? this is the second time this has happened to me, but I'm past the return window
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Seriously, will this "feature" ever be fixed?
I have been waiting for more than a year !!!
Same issue on TP-Link Deco X20, No WAN no LAN ... epic fail.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@TP-Link Come on man! My whole street is under construction and the internet is down. This barely happens where I live so it's kind of a first in the last 3 years... I have now seen that HALF of my smart home appliances which have local network functionality stopped working because your mesh system kills the ethernet port on the main deco when no WAN is up.
This is FRUSTRATING and i feel cheated. How am I supposed to know such a thing when I bought these? You see a port on a device and you ASSUME it works like they always used to work since routers were invented...
Please, allow us to select the WAN port, or designate one automatically and only apply your "smart scan" on one of them... And no, I can't move my wired connections to other sattelites because they are already being used in different parts of the house.
I love this modern tech that just doesn't work unless you are in a lab. And most annoyingly is that nowadays you guys have access to SU MUCH feedback from users and you keep failing in giving a damn about the experience.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 136
Views: 67608
Replies: 275