0
Votes

Add Additional Metadata to LACP SRC IP+DST IP Hash Algorithm

 
0
Votes

Add Additional Metadata to LACP SRC IP+DST IP Hash Algorithm

Add Additional Metadata to LACP SRC IP+DST IP Hash Algorithm
Add Additional Metadata to LACP SRC IP+DST IP Hash Algorithm
Saturday - last edited Saturday
Model: TL-SX3016F  
Hardware Version: V1
Firmware Version: 1.20

The SRC IP XOR DST IP hash algorithm used with LACP LAGs creates a lot of hash collisions that interfere with load balancing of small, statically addressed subnets. For example, consider the following source and destination IP addresses:

  • SRC 192.168.1.1 DST 192.168.1.2
  • SRC 192.168.2.1 DST 192.168.2.2
  • SRC 192.168.3.1 DST 192.168.3.2

 

Ideally, these 3 conversations would be treated as unique data flows across an LACP LAG. However, the simple SRC IP XOR DST IP operation results in identical hashes for all 3 individual conversations and they all get transmitted over the same LAG member interface. This problem could be alleviated by combining the IP header information with some layer 2 information (MAC addresses, vlan IDs, etc).

 

While it is true that this can be partially alleviated by switching to a different hash algorithm, that solution is less ideal because it limits the switch's ability to identify other unique data flows.

 

Thank you for your time.

 

-Newb

#1
Options
2 Reply
Re:Add Additional Metadata to LACP SRC IP+DST IP Hash Algorithm
19 hours ago

  @NewbAdmin 

Thank you for taking the time to share your insights within the TP-Link Community. Your feedback is greatly appreciated and has been formally documented and escalated to our Product Development Division for thorough evaluation.

At this juncture, we are unable to confirm whether the requested enhancement will be implemented or to provide a definitive timeline. We appreciate your understanding of the complexities inherent in our product-planning and development cycles.

Should you have any further suggestions or additional context to offer, please feel free to share them here. All supplementary input will be consolidated and forwarded to the relevant teams for continued consideration.

#2
Options
Re:Add Additional Metadata to LACP SRC IP+DST IP Hash Algorithm
18 hours ago

  @Ethan-TP 

Thank you for taking the time to respond. Please let me know if I can be of any further use beyond making the initial report.

 

-Newb

#3
Options