Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP

Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP

Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
Yesterday - last edited Yesterday
Tags: #Switch
Model: TL-SG2428P  
Hardware Version: V4
Firmware Version:

Hello,


a friend needs a new 24-port switch and would like to gradually switch to Omada in the future.
Currently, an SG2428P or SG2428LP would be among the top choices and within the price range smiley
My friend isn't currently using any PoE devices, but two access points are expected soon.
Since the switch will be running 24/7, power consumption would be of interest to me.
Unfortunately, TP-Link provides no information about this on their website sad
I've done some research, but I'm wondering if that's true?

SG2428P use 15,6 Watts in Standby
SG2428LP use 8,9 Watts in Standby

Is this information correct?
Why does the SG2428P require 6.7 Watts more power without any PoE devices in use?
That's almost double the power consumption.
Why does it need so many more watts?

Thanks :)

  0      
  0      
#1
Options
1 Accepted Solution
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP-Solution
Yesterday - last edited 11 hours ago

  @lukass2000 

 

In comparing the two models here, the SG2428P has 2 fans and the SG2428LP is fanless.  The SG2428P power supply must be larger as it can supply 250W PoE while the SG2428LP is only designed to handle 150W PoE.

1x ER7406 1x OC300 4x SG2008 1x EAP610 3x EAP650-Desktop
Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#2
Options
6 Reply
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP-Solution
Yesterday - last edited 11 hours ago

  @lukass2000 

 

In comparing the two models here, the SG2428P has 2 fans and the SG2428LP is fanless.  The SG2428P power supply must be larger as it can supply 250W PoE while the SG2428LP is only designed to handle 150W PoE.

1x ER7406 1x OC300 4x SG2008 1x EAP610 3x EAP650-Desktop
Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#2
Options
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
Yesterday

Hi  @lukass2000, the standby power consumption is show at datasheet, you may check at SG2428LP(UN)_V1_Datasheet | Omada Network SupportSG2428P(UN)_V5.30_Datasheet | Omada Network Support. SG2428LP use 8.9 Watts in Standby, SG2428P use 14.4 Watts in Standby, the difference is the the use different power supply module, standby power of SG2428P power module is higher. Also SG2428P have Fans also use power.

 

Anyway, back to the demand, if your friend don't need PoE output currently, but will need future, I think SG2428LP is more suitable, it is fanless and lower poe budget/ lower power consumption. It is good choice.

  0  
  0  
#3
Options
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
6 hours ago

  @Penry.huang 
 

I spoke to him again, he will now install two EAP650s and power them via PoE.
The SG2428P would therefore only have the advantage that all ports could be supplied with PoE, or?

Isn't it somehow more efficient when PoE devices are also used, so that the SG2428P has any particular advantage?

Thanks :)

  0  
  0  
#4
Options
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
4 hours ago

Hi  @lukass2000, yes, all port of SG2428P support PoE+ output, and the total PoE output power is higher.

Definitely, SG2428P is a good choice, it is suitable for scenarios the have a lot of powered device like EAP, or don't have so much powered devices yet but want future expansion.

  0  
  0  
#5
Options
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
3 hours ago

  @Penry.huang 
 

The SG2428P is almost identical in price to the SG2428LP.

Therefore, the idea is to just get the SG2428P, even though the SG2428LP certainly has enough PoE ports right now.

But more and more PoE devices are becoming available.
I've read that managed switches vary quite a bit in energy efficiency.
Hence my question about performance, but perhaps I haven't thought it through completely wink
Let's assume I connect the two EAP650 to the switch via PoE (and would fully utilize the Wi-Fi network).
Can we then say that the SG2428P uses 15.6 watts, two EAP650s use a maximum of 13.5 watts, resulting in a total of 42.6 watts?
The SG2428LP would use 8.9 watts, two EAP650s use a maximum of 13.5 watts, resulting in a total of 35.9 watts.
Or is it all dynamic and therefore no comparisons can be made?
Thanks :)

  0  
  0  
#6
Options
Re:Power consumption for SG2428P and SG2428LP
2 hours ago

Hi  @lukass2000, I think your calculation principle is total correct, but the power consumption of switches and access points does indeed vary dynamically.

  0  
  0  
#7
Options

Information

Helpful: 0

Views: 69

Replies: 6

Tags

Switch