New X50 3-pack, bad latency and drop-out issues, super disappointed
New X50 3-pack, bad latency and drop-out issues, super disappointed
I bought an X50 3-pack to replace my existing Netgear Nighthawk MR60/MS60 setup which for the life of me I could not get adequate whole home coverage with even after adding an AX1600 extender. I live in a fairly standard 3-level townhouse, around 2200 sqft, nothing crazy at all.
I was so fed up with the Netgear setup I was super stoked to install the X50s and finally get rid of my WiFi woes. Spent way too much time troubleshooting already.
So now I'm here, with this new X50 pack, and while the coverage is better, I now have a new problem... latency and dropouts.
My gaming PC is downstairs and in the same room as the main X50 that is connected to the internet router. The latency to the internet on my desktop will seemingly at random just spike out of nowhere and sometimes will also drop out completely for a couple of seconds resulting in packet loss. Obviously not good for online gaming as it basically makes it unplayable when you're in competitive matches. Here's a screen of a continous ping showing the latency spiking all over the place. This particular screenshot isn't even showing the worst of it as it frequently spikes up to 1000+ms and with timeouts:
On the Netgear Nighthawks, while the coverage wasn't great, I would get a SOLID 10/11 constant ms ping with almost zero spikes and no timeouts whatsoever.
My PC setup is a ASUS B550-F Gaming (Wi-Fi) mobo with an onboard Intel AX200 160MHz Wifi/Bluetooth card. I've tried all sorts of different driver versions from the recommended ASUS version to random other ones I've found elsewhere and the latest version (23.30.0.6) from intel, nothing seems to make a difference driver wise:
I've also tried putting the Decos into AP mode which didn't do anything. Tried a myriad of other settings within the Deco app such as locking my PC to a specific Deco (the one closest to), forcing 2.4 GHz band, turning off Mesh, ran network optimization, etc. to no avail. Firmware is all up to date as well.
I'm at a loss for words at this point and am extremely disappointed. TP-Link Decos were fairly well reviewed and like I said, I was excited to finally rid myself of WiFi problems, only to be seriously frustrated and disappointed yet again. The product itself looks slick, was easy to setup, the App is great... but it's all out the window if it's unreliable.
Why is this so difficult? Does no one make a good product anymore? I thought shelling out $300 would be enough to get reliable Wi-Fi.
Any tips / help would be appreciated at this point as now it's looking like I'll have to switch back to the Netgears or hard-wire my desktop I guess (which kind of defeats the purpose of a Mesh Wi-Fi network...).
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Cgarn No i haven't found a fix yet, sadly. Been too busy to dig into it any further or call support. Honestly might have to switch back to my Netgear system and try and get a refund on these Decos which I'm not sure is even possible as I had them sittign in the box for a while... Sigh..
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Vitszy Can you provide a factual description of your configuration?
If the laptop is close to the main Deco, how come the Deco in the garage is the closest?
Is the wifi active on your ISP modem, or only on the Deco?
How are your Deco interconnected?
Does the issue happen with a device hardwired onto the main Deco? With a device connected by wifi to the main Deco?
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@yves_b Laptop and PC are on the bottom floor, same floor as garage, 1 room over. I had the 'garage' Deco in the same room as the laptop/PC as well, connected via a long cable, to the internet modem in the garage, and observed the same issue. No difference if I move the 'garage' Deco to be in the same room as the laptop & PC, or if I keep it in the garage.
I will try running a cable from the Deco to the laptop or PC and see if the drops / latency spikes stop and report back.
Yes I believe the internet modem also emits Wifi signal which is used for the TV box. When I moved the Deco away from the internet modem (by running a long cable from the garage into the room next door) it made no difference.
Main Deco (bottom floor/garage) is connected by cable to the internet modem. 2nd Deco is connected to the main Deco wirelessly and is on the 2nd floor. 3rd Deco is connected to the 2nd Deco wirelessly and is on the 3rd floor. All components in the TP Link app and my laptop & desktop show full connectivity bars all green health.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Vitszy The wifi of the Internet model has another name than the wifi of the Deco?
I assume you eliminated the possibility of a defective cable or a defective port.
I would also try swaping Deco, to use another Deco as main.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@yves_b Update, I reset all three Decos and swapped a different unit to be the main one connected to the router, and so far that seems to have resolved the issue. I'm no longer getting any latency spikes or timeouts.
Frustrating to say the least, since nothing fundamentally is different other than using a different unit for the main. Makes no sense.
At least it's fixed.. for now..
Thanks for the suggestion.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Same thing here.
I had cheaper TP-Link WiFi extender products:
TP-Link RE450
TP-Link WA860RE
I wanted to upgrade for something better; because of all features I bought "future proof" Deco X50 2 pack + 1 pack (3 devices).
PROBLEMS:
Poor coverage:
Its so poor, that with 3 devices in my house I have less WiFi signal then with RE450 + WA860RE.
Its so bad, that sometimes there is even NO signal.
Poor speed:
Main device speed: 1000Mbit
3 metres up from main device there is second one.
You want to know speed of 2nd device?
300Mbit.
One concrete wall and speed drops from 1000 to 300Mbit.
Bad latency and drop-out issues from main device:
Every minute there is ping dropout: 25ms / 27ms / 24ms / 26ms / 1368ms / 25ms / 27ms / 24ms / 26ms / 25ms / 24ms / 0ms / 27ms / 25ms / 27ms / 24ms / 26ms / 1368ms / 25ms / 27ms / 24ms / 26ms / 25ms / 24ms / 0ms / 27ms / etc.
By all meaning, this product is super disappointing.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 2
Views: 1913
Replies: 16
Voters 0
No one has voted for it yet.