WPA Authentication times out/failed every now and then but after some time succesfull
This thread has been locked for further replies. You can start a new thread to share your ideas or ask questions.
I experience a for me weird connection lost and reconnect problem.
I've Omada AP contoller (V4.1.5) that's controlling 3 AP's: 2 EAP245 and 1 outdoor eap225.
The use of the Omage AP control program makes sure the definitions of the AP's are identical as they're applied to all AP's.
So SSID's and WPA2 secure string is all the same for all AP's.
As of the installation begin of this year but now as of the juni release more ofter the WiFi is instable.
While connected and working client it suddenly looses its connection and attempts to reconnect.
Reconnect takes some time.
In the logs i see "WPA Authentication times out/failed"
But after a minute or so the client does get connected.
All type clients experience this problems: android, windows, chromebook.
The AP's provide 2,4 and 5 GHz using the same SSID.
I've reset the most setting back to standard.
I did orginally use Fast Roaming and band steering. Did uncheck them for now, that improved it a bit but not enough.
When checked these I noticed the client kept conencted but lost internet connectivity.
On android changing "using mac address to random mac" speeds up the relinking.
What could cause this behaviour and what to change here in the conguration ?
The DHCP is delivered using an Edgemax router. The DHCP logs do not reveal much here. Looks like the AP handshake somewhere fails within the alloted time.
DHCP is very busy, but seems the message does not pass:
17:53:31 Information xxx daemon dhcpd3 DHCPOFFER on x.x.x.101 to MyMACaddr via switch0
17:53:31 Information xxx daemon dhcpd3 DHCPDISCOVER from MyMACaddr via switch0
17:53:29 ... same message over and over again...
17:53:29
17:53:28
17:53:28
17:53:28
17:53:28
17:53:23
17:53:23
17:53:21
17:53:21
17:53:20
17:53:20
17:53:19
17:53:19
17:53:18
17:53:18
17:53:16
17:53:16
17:53:15
17:53:15
The omada logs show less details:
7-8-2020 17:53:44 Information MyOmadacontroller local1 1 2020-08-07T15:53:45.934Z - Omada Controller - - [client:MyMACaddr] is connected to [ap:D8-0D-17-94-07-34] with SSID MySSID on channel 1.
7-8-2020 17:53:44 Information MyOmadacontroller local1 1 2020-08-07T15:53:45.900Z - Omada Controller - - [client:MyMACaddr] is disconnected from SSID MySSID on [ap:1C-3B-F3-A1-62-DE] (10s connected, 1.73KB).
7-8-2020 17:53:41 Information MyOmadacontroller local1 1 2020-08-07T15:53:42.721Z - Omada Controller - - [client:MyMACaddr] is connected to [ap:1C-3B-F3-A1-62-DE] with SSID MySSID on channel 11.
7-8-2020 17:53:41 Information MyOmadacontroller local1 1 2020-08-07T15:53:42.694Z - Omada Controller - - [client:MyMACaddr] is disconnected from SSID MySSID on [ap:D8-0D-17-94-07-34] (7s connected, 2.74KB).
7-8-2020 17:53:14 Information MyOmadacontroller local1 1 2020-08-07T15:53:15.782Z - Omada Controller - - [client:MyMACaddr] is connected to [ap:D8-0D-17-94-07-34] with SSID MySSID on channel 108.
7-8-2020 17:53:14 Information MyOmadacontroller local1 1 2020-08-07T15:53:15.756Z - Omada Controller - - [client:MyMACaddr] is disconnected from SSID MySSIDon on [ap:D8-0D-17-94-07-34] (17s connected, 7.78KB).
I'm reading on the subject "WPA Authentication times out/failed" discussions on changing Beacon interval of DTIM period. Do not feel comfortable with this yet to start experiments.
In the mean time the customers on the site are getting upset on this instable WiFi.
Any thoughts?
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
Dear @CarbonPepper,
May I check the current firmware version of your Omada EAP? How about the version of your Omada Controller?
There was new firmware released for the EAP245 V3 and Omada Software Controller last week.
You may upgrade the firmware of your EAP and upgrade the Omada Controller to have a try.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Fae Thanks,
Controller version was:
Controller Version:4.1.5
Model:OC200 1.0
Firmware Version:1.7.0 Build 20200703 Rel.59609
Hardware Controller Firmware
Current Version: OC200 1.0
After upgrade
----------------
Controller Version:4.2.4
Model:OC200 1.0
Firmware Version:1.7.1 Build 20201016 Rel.62818
Hardware Controller Firmware
Current Version: [CHECK FOR UPGRADE]
I will observe for improvements.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@CarbonPepper There is another newer controller, 4.2.8 but it hasn't hit the oc200 yet, only standalone. @Fae any idea when it will come to oc200?
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
At the end of the day..I bought the OC200 to control the three Omada AP's.
However still the same.. lots of WPA authentication failures.
All AP's have been restarted several times. HW reset done and loaded from the OC200 again.
When moving my smartphone, most often I find myself runing on 4G+ instead of WiFi as it can not roam between the AP's.
Looking to the logs it appears there are WPA authentication errors.
When I change fixed Mac.address to use random Mac. address it will most often connect.
When close to the AP and wait long enough I can connect, so the AP/SSID/accespassword is correct (more over.. the SSID's are maintained on one place: the OC200 so must be all set to the same)
The DHCP service is comming from Edgemax.
I must say - sofar i'm disappointed by the wifi quality of these omada AP's. I could think of that 3 AP's must be able to cooperate and cover an average size home. However the 5 GHz seems to be low powered
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Dear @sjon,
At the end of the day..I bought the OC200 to control the three Omada AP's.
However still the same.. lots of WPA authentication failures.
All AP's have been restarted several times. HW reset done and loaded from the OC200 again.
Sorry for any trouble caused. I've reported your case to the R&D team for further investigation.
May I check the firmware of your OC200 and EAPs? Could you draw a simple network topology to show us how the devices are connected? How many wireless clients are usually connected to APs?
I could think of that 3 AP's must be able to cooperate and cover an average size home. However the 5 GHz seems to be low powered
How far are the 3 EAPs away from each other? Where are they installed, on the ceiling or on the wall? How high are they from the ground? Is there any obstacle like thick walls from the EAP to the wireless clients?
You may refer to this guide to optimize the wireless performance and see if it helps. https://www.tp-link.com/support/faq/2511/
Below is the instruction for the coverage of ceiling AP for your reference.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Same problem for me here.
I have a NEW EAP245 and I have the WPA Authentication Timeout on many devices. I am running the latest firmware.
This really makes me mad because I bought this AC1750 to upgrade my Wifi to something faster and now many devices cannot connect. I am not happy. The good news is that I still have the old Wifi AP and so I went back to using that. So did I just waste a bunch of money on this tp-link AP? Do I throw it in the garbage?
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Dear @mackworth,
There is another newer controller, 4.2.8 but it hasn't hit the oc200 yet, only standalone. @Fae any idea when it will come to oc200?
It has been released for the OC200, please refer to this post.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi all,
The WPA Authentication Timeout/Failed may be prompted on the Omada SDN Controller in two situations:
- There is a packet loss in the wireless associated handshake process, which causes the handshake process to timeout
- The wireless password is input wrong when connecting to the SSID on the wireless client.
So please ensure your wireless clients can get a strong signal strength from the SSID, and the wireless password is input correctly first.
Besides, please make sure your Omada Controller and EAPs are all up to date. (The Omada Controller v4.2.8 has been released)
If the signal strength is strong enough and the password is input correctly, please try providing the info below for further analysis.
1. What else phenomenon do you notice in your network except for WPA Authentication times out/failed on the Omada Controller?
2. What devices(brand/model/OS) are you using in your network? What devices are suffering from the problem?
For example, iPhone12 with iOS 14.3, Samsung SM-A217F with Android 10.
3. Does the problem only occur on certain devices or only exist on a specific band (2.4GHz or 5GHz), specific SSID?
4. Does the issue occur regularly and how often would it happen for your case? Can you reproduce the problem steadily?
5. How do you get the devices to be connected finally? Would a reboot help for your case?
6. Do you configure any advanced features like Band Steering, Airtime Fairness, Fast Roaming, Mesh or 802.11 Rate Control?
Note: they are disabled on the Omada Controller by default unless you enable it manually.
7. Are you using Omada Software Controller or OC200? What's the version of the Omada Controller?
For example, Omada Controller v4.2.8 - Windows.
8. How many EAPs do you have in total, what's the detailed firmware version of your EAPs?
For example, only one EAP245 V3 whose firmware is 5.0.0 Build 20200918.
TP-Link team will try the best to figure out the problem, your feedback is much appreciated!
If you have any further clues, please feel free to leave your comments. Thank you for your cooperation and support!
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Fae why I don't get any logs for these WPA Authentication Timeout / Failure?
On Notifications, Client tab, I marked the Alert checkbox for all the authentication failed / expired, but still no Logs. I wonder if the 62 issues I have are related to a password thing, but I have no way of figuring out the device..
Also, I realized that number increases as I'm roaming, and roaming doesn't seem to be as fast as used to be. I'm on a conference call and it drops for about half a second when I roam from one AP to another: 3 stories house, 1 AP per floor, wall mounted at the height of about 11 inches.
3 EAP 225 v3 firmware 5.0.0 Build 20200918 Rel. 58628 - (wired to a TL-SG108PE 2.0 switch)
Omada Controller 4.2.8 running on an Ubuntu Linux x86
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Reply'n to the question on my config.
2 AP are in-house: wooden floors. Stone walls.
1 on base ground, on 2 m from floor on the wall in the corridor of the house. The other one is at the 2nd floor (ceiling),
1 AP outside
Distance between the AP
All AP's are full power at 5 Ghz.
On base ground being on the other side of the wall of the corridor the AP does not get with the 5 Ghz power. The AP from outside does a beter job getting the signal passing through the windows. Makes the living room working on 2,4 GHz and less likely to get to the 5 GHz of any AP.
Bad connection experience is when at the same time the WPA timeouts are reported.
I just happen to read there is an upgrade, so I did apply these yesterday. Looking at the report of 1 day it looks like the amount of WPA authentication timeout has reduced. Will keep an eye on it and see if i can again have a common SSID on both bands on all AP's. As i learning in the past when i do so connection was terrible. Only improved when every AP has a unique SSID in a specific Ghz band.
|
EAP245(EU) v3.0
|
5.0.0
|
|
EAP245(EU) v3.0
|
5.0.0
|
|
EAP225-Outdoor(EU) v1.0
|
5.0.0
|
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 1
Views: 44867
Replies: 57
Voters 0
No one has voted for it yet.