DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs

DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs

DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
a week ago - last edited a week ago
Model: TL-SG2428P  
Hardware Version: V5
Firmware Version:

This is my Omada network.

 

Last week I posted that recently I getting an email from Omada saying that log entries are out of storage space. So I guessed I have to clear it. This message re-apeared in a week (~10K log entries). So my post was how to reduce log entries. So were the answers. As a bad workaround I disabled almost all notification to avoid that 1K logs/day.

 

Yestareday, I asked in another post ,after upgrading switch's firmware, all POE clients (APs and OC200) were not powered (once after powering back on the switch and once after several hours). So I downgraded back the firmware and hopefully, that solved the issue.

 

Earlier today, I saw my network icon on my Ubuntu machine, getting disconnected and connecting back after ~10 seconds.

 

I have this feeling now that it is somehow all connected!!!

 

1) I created a python script to monitor my network (Switch 192.168.0.1, OC200 192.168.0.2 and APs 192.168.0.3-192.168.0.8)

2) I enabled back Omada's logging.

 

Python script show some connection lose to some AP (03, 07), losing connection to Switch (01).

 

 

and just to have a log that about 12hrs since I turned back on Omada's logs, and I have ~1K of log entries, all about DHCP allocation (some of them are Lan ports and not Wifi).

 

  0      
  0      
#1
Options
6 Reply
Re:DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
a week ago - last edited a week ago

  @guyd2 

The log comes from the router. It is a new feature added to the Omada V5.15 which tons of users requested on the forum for a more granular and detailed log for everything like DHCP. 

More detailed log will come to the future Omada Controller.

The majority of these logs are not concerning or useful for most users. It can serve a diagnosis purpose unless you know what you need to distill from them. 


I am not sure how accurate your script is. 

If you could provide more details and monitor the actual connectivity on these mentioned, and "problematic" devices. I don't think that would be a concern unless this part has bee confirmed and verified. 

  1  
  1  
#2
Options
Re:DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
a week ago

  @Clive_A 

 

Thank you for your kindly reply.

1. It it possible to disable this log feature ?

2. After exported logs to CSV file, I filter to certain IP, and I witness 2 major issues(see attached image):

  • One IP (Android TV), connected using cable holds 40% of all entries. It has a 1 minutes apart. Do you have any guess why is it ?
  • Some entries of same IP happens in seconds apart. Is it still expected behaviour of DHCP server ?

 

Regarding my Python script - I can share it if you want.

In general - it pings APs and Switch every few seconds.

 

Appreciate any thought/ lead.

 

Guy

 

 

  0  
  0  
#3
Options
Re:DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
a week ago

  @guyd2 

 

The DHCP server isnt actuve in that it doesnt forcefully start handing our IP allocations.  It is a response service - a client must go "give me an IP" before it responds.

 

I have a few devices on my business network that constantly ask for IP addresses - both of them running android - regardless of what DHCP server is use (gateway, switch, somethign else entirely) and what the DHCP lease time is set to.

 

Its of no particular concern to me, its just the way these devices behave. 

 

It is possible it could also be trigerred by marginal WiFi conenctions that drop and then come back - like if the device was at the edge of the range, or lots of interference so the device keeps dropping and coming back, naturally triggering a DHCP request to the network

Main: ER8411 x1, SG3428X x1, SG3452 x1, SG2428LP x1, SG3210 x1, SG2218P x1, SG2008P x3, ES208G x1, EAP650 x6 Remote: ER7206 v2 x1, ER605 v2 x3, SG2008P x2, EAP650 x2, ES205G x1 Controller: OC300
  0  
  0  
#4
Options
Re:DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
a week ago

  @guyd2 

guyd2 wrote

  @Clive_A 

 

Thank you for your kindly reply.

1. It it possible to disable this log feature ?

2. After exported logs to CSV file, I filter to certain IP, and I witness 2 major issues(see attached image):

  • One IP (Android TV), connected using cable holds 40% of all entries. It has a 1 minutes apart. Do you have any guess why is it ?
  • Some entries of same IP happens in seconds apart. Is it still expected behaviour of DHCP server ?

 

Regarding my Python script - I can share it if you want.

In general - it pings APs and Switch every few seconds.

 

Appreciate any thought/ lead.

 

Guy

 

 

 

1. You should Wireshark and see how the TV reacts to the DHCP.

I don't have a guess on that. I am not responsible for any other products and I don't know how they work. I only know the DHCP would work fine on the Omada gears most of the time. 

2. Note this, the DHCP requires two parts to work together. The DHCP server and the DHCP client. You cannot call the server a problem before you verify the behavior of the client is normal. 

For anything else, in networking, it is likewise. 

3. The python script is a simple ping test to the clients. Do you read the actual results or the debug log of it? If the pinged device is a wireless one, it could lose a packet. It does not mean it is a problem with the DHCP server. 

If there is a delay, or you set the ping with certain parameters, and it is delayed in responding, it would be considered a loss. 

But that does not mean anything for a DHCP server. It assigns the IP and that's it. The rest of the network interaction does not involve too much of the DHCP. 

  0  
  0  
#5
Options
Re:DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
a week ago - last edited a week ago

  @Clive_A 

 

1. OK - I'll have to lear a bit how to work with it.

2. Totaly understood. I have to say that set it to static (on TV side), stopped DHCP re-allocation.

3. I ping only APs (that are wired). Networrk tools (part of Omada's interface) verified that all cable are as needed (in case that you still don't rely on the end device that verifies that all, including shielding was OK). 

 

Attached ping function. Feel free to advice.

 

 

my concern is that some disconnects happen.

 

Best,

Guy

  0  
  0  
#6
Options
Re:DHCP server re-allocation multiple times, multiple IPs
Friday
Can you please construct how to disable logging that specific entries ?
  0  
  0  
#7
Options