ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"

ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"

ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"
ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"
2 weeks ago - last edited a week ago
Model: ER605 (TL-R605)  
Hardware Version: V2
Firmware Version: 2.2.6

I am trying to setup QoS for my VoIP phones.  I setup a separate network (192.168.10.0/24 VLAN 10) and then configure an IP Group for that network called VoIP.  I then create a class rule in QoS called Voice set it to class 1, assign it the VoIP group to it and set DSCP to "Any".  I then assign Class 1 to 20% of the bandwidth, Class  2 to 5% Class 3 to 5% and Others is 70% by default.  I only have the one class rule.

 

When  connect my laptop to this network and do a speed test, I can see it limiting it to 20% of the available bandwidth, and can see in the routers admin utility that Class 1 shows activity during the speed test.  All is good so far.

 

Now I want VoIP to have the highest priority, so I change the DSCP from "Any" to EF, which is gives VoIP the highest priority.  As soon as I do this, everything goes south.  Now when I run a speed test I can see that I am now using 70% of the available bandwidth and when looking at the QoS monitor it shows the traffic going out over the "Others" class.  Upon further investigation, setting DSCP to any value other than Any will cause the traffic to go out over Others and not Class 1.

 

What am I doing wrong and how do I get my VoIP traffic to go out over Class1 with the highest priority and the correct bandwidth limit?

 

Help!!

 

Thanks,

 

 

John

  0      
  0      
#1
Options
1 Accepted Solution
Re:ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"-Solution
a week ago - last edited a week ago

Hi  @TestingJohn 

 

Thanks for posting here.

 

Please refer to the following guide and test again:

How to configure Quality of Service on Omada Gateway via Omada Controller

 

If still the same, please share with us the following info:

1. Screenshots of the mentioned config pages;

2. How did you verify it's not working? better with some screenshots;

3. The bandwidth of your ISP;

4. The topology of your network.

Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#2
Options
3 Reply
Re:ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"-Solution
a week ago - last edited a week ago

Hi  @TestingJohn 

 

Thanks for posting here.

 

Please refer to the following guide and test again:

How to configure Quality of Service on Omada Gateway via Omada Controller

 

If still the same, please share with us the following info:

1. Screenshots of the mentioned config pages;

2. How did you verify it's not working? better with some screenshots;

3. The bandwidth of your ISP;

4. The topology of your network.

Recommended Solution
  0  
  0  
#2
Options
Re:ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"
a week ago

  @Vincent-TP Thank you for the reply.  I have enclosed pictures of my configuration, but will explain it here as well.  2 Networks configured as follows:

 

Network/LAN: (see picture LAN Config.jpg)

Name  VLAN  IP Address       Subnet Mask       DHCP Server

LAN        1      192.168.0.1     255.255.255.0      Enabled

VoIP       10     192.168.10.1  255.255.255.0       Enabled

 

 

Network/VLAN: (see pictures VLAN.jpg and VLAN ports.jpg)

ID      VLAN ID     Name      Ports                       Description

1             1            vlan1       2(untag) 5(untag)      LAN1

2            10           vlan10     3(untag) 4(untag)      VoIP

3          4096         vlan4096  1(untag)                   WAN

 

 

 

 

Preferences/IP Group/IP Group (see picture IPGroup.jpg)

ID       Group Name       Address Name        Description

3         Data                    Data                        Computer Network

4         Voice_Group       Voice                       Phone Network

 

 

Preferences/IP Group/IP Address (see picture IP Address.jpg)

ID       Name    IP Address Type   IP Address Range   IP Address/Mask   Description

2         Data      IP Address/Mask  192.168.0.0/24       192.168.0.0/24       Computer Network

3         Voice     IP Address/Mask  192.168.10.0/24     192.168.10.0/24     Phone Network

 

 

Transmission/Quality of Service/Class Rule (see picture Class Rule Any. jpg)

Rule   Qos Class     Status     Local Address    Remote Address    DSCP        Service Type

1         Class 1          Enabled Voice_Group      IPGROUP_ANY     any            all

 

 

Transmission/Quality of Service/Bandwidth Control (see picture bandwidth control.jpg)

Index    Status       Direction       Inbound/Outbound Bandwidth    Class 1     Class 2     Class 3   Others

WAN     Enabled    Both              350000Kbps/40000Kbps              5%            1%           1%           93%

 

 

My laptop is connected to Port 3 which is the VoIP network.  It properly gets an  IP address 192.168.10.100 from DHCP on the router (see picture IP Config.jpg).  Notice that the Class Rule has DSCP set to "any".

 

 

Run a speed test and can see that my bandwidth is 18.10Mbps Down and 2.21Mbps Up and I can see from the WAN Online Statistics page (on the router) that the traffic is going out on Class 1 (see picture Success.jpg). 

 

 

This works as expected, but I want my phone traffic to have the highest priority (EF).  So all I did is go into the Class Rule (Transmission/Quality of Service/Class Rule) and change the DSCP setting from "any" to "EF" (see picture Class Rule EF.jpg). 

 

 

I then rerun my speed test.  Now get 330.62Mbps Down and 38.04Mbps Up, and can see from the WAN Online Statistics page (on the router) that the traffic is going out on Others (see picture Failure.jpg). 

 

 

Setting DSCP to any setting other than "any" causes the traffic to go on the VoIP network to go out over Others class and not Class 1.  This is a real problem for me and I am not sure what I did wrong in my configuration or how to correct this.

 

I surely need some help and guidance here.  Thanks!!

 

  0  
  0  
#3
Options
Re:ER605 QoS not working when setting DSCP to anything other than "Any"
a week ago
For the purpose of the test above, I had a single computer connected to Port 5 on the ER605 and my laptop connected to Port 3 on the ER605 and the WAN connected to Port 1 on the ER605. That's it. As simple as I could make this test to demonstrate my problem where I cannot set DSCP to anything other than "any" without it ignoring the class rule and sending traffic out Others and not Class 1!
  0  
  0  
#4
Options