@Kevin_Z 

All tests mentioned in my first post was made without leaving home - looking on HS100. I have do this by setting my and my wife's cells wifi connection "on" and "off" - to simulate those three scenarios. I was also looking in Deco App in third device - to see when devices was online and offline and wait some time after that, but action didnt run.

Both my HS100 are: HW: 2.0, Fw: 1.5.4

@Kevin_Z

Both HS100 was removed and re-added, after that i was trying to simulate scenario 1, and nothing changed. Still not working when only one of selected devices connected to network (plugs where on, thats ok) and after a while this device was disconnected and plugs didnt off (wifes cell is away home at this moment).

Also automation rules needs to be re-created because after removing HS100 - previous rules dissapired.

On HS100 Boxes on label i see: Model: HS100(EU) Ver:3.1

@Kevin_Z Thx for reply, but thats not good. Are there any plans to change it to work better ?

If your R&D could add additional tab "conditions" to automations rules in future release of Deco update, thats will be great, on example:

- Time settings

- Triggers

- Conditions

- Action

- Name

In conditions you could check current states of devices (similar to Triggers: smart devices, network devices, etc). And on example a working rule "HS_disable" could look like this:

- Time settings: always

- Triggers: Two phones selected, triggered by any device, when disconnected

- Conditions: Two phones selected, all of them, state is disconnected

- Action: disable plugs

- Name: HS_disable

Second situation in which it would be helpful are messages in which the router asks whether to disable the rule because it is executed too often. Look at my first rule "HS_enable". Even when we are at home, but e.g. the wife often moves around the garden,  every time her phone gets in range, deco tries to run a rule. This rule could look like this:

- Time settings: always

- Triggers: Two phones selected, triggered by any device, when connected

- Conditions: Two plugs selected, all of them, state is off

- Action: enable plugs

- Name: HS_enable

The rules could work as now, triggered by selected trigger, but if conditions are not met, action will not be launched. Maybe in future releases you could even add logical operators to conditions (XOR, AND, OR, etc..), but now a simple conditions thats looks similat to triggers, will significantly increase automation capabilities and will gets yours product to higher level.

If you could confirm if this feature will be in future releases or not, that will be great. I want to know what to do with my Deco and Kasa devices - to give them back, or wait, because it does not meet my requirements in current situation.

@Kevin_Z Even yesterday i had a strange situation with automation rules, i will write you timeline of day:

8:00 AM - im leaving home, wife stays, plugs stays enabled

4:00 PM - im back to home, wife still in home, plugs stays enabled, triggered automation rule "HS_enabled" runs

After going back to home, i have removed them from Deco network, and re-added and re-created rules as you wrote me in your recent messages.

6:30 PM - im leaving home, wife stays in home, plugs stays enabled

7:10 PM - im back to home, wife stays in home, plugs stays enabled, triggered automation rule "HS_enabled" runs

9:00 PM - we are in home, wife turn off phone on night, my phone still connected, plugs are disabled

As you see, rule have been triggered by two actions, 1st device from selected on 6:30PM, and 2nd device from selected on 9:00PM.

Its not normaly expected action. Additional conditions could be a great solution for this, and many others situations.

@Kevin_Z Below some todays log. I leave home at 7:33am and back at 8:49am. Wife was at home alk time. Then i leave at 10:05am, and wife leave at 10:24am.

I came back at 2:54pm. As you see, additional conditions will be cery helpfull.

I wonder what was going at night and morning where we was at home. I think that HS_on rule was triggered everytime when her phone has switched between Decos (iPhone 7).  

@Kevin_Z Can you answer to my posts about additional conditions ?

@Kevin_Z Yes, you make clear. I understand the current state completely. That's the idea the creators had, and that's how it works now.

It's great to hear that the "conditions" suggestion will be forwarded to developers, and I have nothing to do but wait for the future updates.

Thanks.