Since @DarrenL needs to use different source IPs for outgoing traffic , I would have thought using One-to-One NAT was more appropriate ? The only issue with that would be that it would forward ALL...

@jakobp I'd be interested to hear what they have to say. Most ISPs use a DHCP Relay agent because their DHCP server is on an internal network and not accessible directly from a users connection. I...

@jakobp I've been doing some Wireshark captures with various devices to see how they process DHCP/ARP requests. My ISP uses PPPoE so I can't test with that, but I've tested connecting devices to the...

@jakobp I'm located in Austria, it's a local fiber to the home provider. That might mean they will at least look into the problem. I was afraid that it was going to be a UK ISP using the BT/Openreach...

@jakobp Interesting! I'll have to have a good read through the RFC myself. I wonder if, in the case of the ER605, the ARP announce is sent when the ISP systems are still finalising the IP allocation,...

@jakobp Is there a chance you could get a packet capture using the router that works, so we can see any difference in the DHCP/ARP conversations