Do I need to throw my new Deco's in the trash?
I have a brand new set of 3x Deco M4 and after a whole day of trying to fit it in my network, I think it is time to give up and throw it in the trash.
Situation:
I have a house with 3 floors made of concrete. Wifi is not going through the floors at all. I have an existing network structure. On all floors there is a wired internet connection where a switch distributes it to all the wires devices on that floor. Everything that I can connect wired, is connected wired. So wireless is mostly for phones, tablets, e-readers, alexa, tasmota's and other devices that have no option to connect them wired. I also have several IoT devices for home automation. These IoT devices are all on fixed IP addresses for numorous reasons. My network runs on IP range 10.0.0.x. Changing the IP range is extremely time consuming because of the devices on fixed addresses, scripts depending on it and so on. I use a router after my modem to keep my network stable (same IP range) to be able to switch internet provider without problems.
What I was expecting from the Deco M4's:
I was planning to put one M4 on each floor and connect these via their ethernet port to my wired network.
To my opinion this is what most people expect. Connecting them wired also saves 50% of the wireless bandwidth.
Image of the planned setup:
So what went wrong:
1) The ethernet backhaul does not seem to work in this way. If I want to connect the Deco #2 and #3 wired, it needs to connect to the ethernet port of Deco #1. This is impossible in my case because it requires pulling a 2nd cable to floor #2 and #3. Stupid, because ethernet is already available there.
2) The IP range of the wireless is changed and cannot run on the same range as the wired range (10.0.0.x). So that means most IoT devices do not work without a lott of hassle.
3) So then I though about setting the Deco's to Access Point mode. Then they are all on the same network! But when setting the Deco's to Access Point mode, the App tells me it cannot find the Deco's anymore. So I have no way to change their configuration (or change it back to router mode) and no way to check if the use the wired connection. I am not sure that problem #1 is solved by this, probably I still need to connect deco #2 and #3 to deco #1's ethernet port?
4) I'm not really sure what functionality I lose in AP mode but I am afraid that most handy features are simply not available. Something I dont like either (because I paid for them) but may be it is acceptable...
5) Wireless range of the deco's have a very hard time going through my concrete floors. So connecting them wired is a must. It's a pretty normal construction type in my country....
So my conclusion is that If I am not willing to pull extra cables for the deco's, it is not going to work. Right? Pulling extra cables is not possible, so I end up throwing the deco's in the garbage.... unless some brilliant mind here knows a way around it.
Note that problem #3: Deco's not found in App after switching to AP mode, is very anoying. I need to reset the devices and completely start over again!
When I started the setup, I thought that TP-Link really did very well to make it user friendly. But after a day of total frustration......