PX50 Powerline Connectivity vs AV600

PX50 Powerline Connectivity vs AV600

PX50 Powerline Connectivity vs AV600
PX50 Powerline Connectivity vs AV600
Thursday
Model: TL-PA4010 KIT  
Hardware Version:
Firmware Version: Ver 3.0

I have an existing Powerline network from my home to my adjacent garage based on AV600 units (TL-PA4010 and/or TL-WPA4220), solely to allow me remote access to a CCTV system in the garage.  My router is positioned in my home, connected to the Powerline adaptor by Ethernet cable. AV600 connectivity to the garage is flaky - sometimes it allows remote connection, sometimes not, even when the adaptors both show as paired. Adaptors can go unpaired, sometimes re-pair themselves, sometimes re-pair just by unplugging one from the mains and plugging in again. I suspect that the garage is on the range limit of AV600 capability. Is there anything about the PX50 Powerline standard which is likely to improve Powerline range and connection stability if I replaced the AV600 with PX50?  

  0      
  0      
#1
Options
2 Reply
Re:PX50 Powerline Connectivity vs AV600
Saturday

  @BrianRJ 

 

Hi,

 

I assume you are referring to the "G.hn" Powerline standard.

 

Powerline performance is really unpredictable. A "G.hn" Powerline adapter might or might not work better in your environment.

 

TP-Link advertises both, their Homeplug AV and their G.hn Powerline adapters as "up to 300 meters". However, this number is rather hypothetical.

 

I happen to own a set of TP-Link TL-PA7017P adapters that are rated as "up to 1000 Mbps" and a set of G.hn adapters made by Comtrend rated as "1 Gbps", which is the same as 1000 Mbps.
When plugged into the same two wall outlets inside my home I measured the following data throughput numbers.

 

TP-Link TL-PA7017P:    150 Mbps DL / 182 Mbps UL
Comtrend G.hn:             133 Mbps DL / 123 Mbps UL

 

A higher throughout at a given distance should theoretically mean a more stable connection and better possible range.

 

So, in my particular environment the G.hn standard does not perform better than the "older" Homeplug AV2 standard. 

  1  
  1  
#2
Options
Re:PX50 Powerline Connectivity vs AV600
Saturday

  @woozle 

Thanks very much for your reply. Exactly the kind of feedback I was looking for. Much appreciated.

  0  
  0  
#3
Options