Hey,

@Frantisek_67,

Thank you for the tip. I will definitely try suggested time based triggers. It could be viable workaround to make it truely automatic. As for the temperature triggers I dont want to add so many tresholds because I use it on rarely inhabited property where temperature can fluctuate from negative to above 30 C.

@Wayne-TP,

App is updated with updated sensors and hub. Yes, enabling automation manually shows popup window that condition was met and prompt to turn it on. However I am trying to turn on this and other automations and actions with shortcut as described above and this way the trigger does not work on shortcut press. It only activates when reaching the temperature treshold specified in said automation. That's mine and i believe Fratisek's point. Isn't it possible to trigger it the same way via shortcut?

Thank you.

  @Masl0 

I agree that a fix would be nice but the workaround is easy to implement.  The problem arises when the temperature is already below your target when you enable the automation as it only triggers when the temperature crosses the threshold. I fixed my automation by simply adding several "when" triggers to the turn on automation for several temperatures below my target low.  How many will depend upon how low you expect the worst case low will be.  Likewise adding several "when" triggers to your turn off automation for termperatures above your target will turn it off when it crosses any of the extra triggers above your target high temperature. 

All that said, it is important to remember that this is not really intended to be a thermostat. In most cases, it would be better to get an actual themostat to control your heater and plug it into your Tapo smart plug.  That way you can simply turn it on and off when you want to (or using an automation for a specific time for example) and let a device that is designed for the task you are trying to do it more reliably.  This is the approach I took for my greenhouse heater using a BN-LINK digital thermostat and it greatly simplified the integration and realiability. I can turn it on and off remotely and I now use the temperature sensor automations (with multiple when triggers above) to alert me when the temperature falls outside my target range. The alert notification actually triggered when my heater developed a ground fault and triggered the GFCI the smart plug was into, saving me from damage to my plants.  

  @DumbAu 

I get that this workaround is possible but not ideal. For example, when target temperature is lets say 20C and temperature can range from -20C to 35C and I set it every 2C its 20 when conditions and I still have to wait for temperature to change accordingly which can take days. It says for the last 24h real temperature reading from this sensor was 6,9-7,8C.

Thermostat is just device that automaticaly regulates temperature. This temperature sensor with hub combo has all the features for that and more. Not sure where you read intended uses for this device but I wanted it as a easy temporary solution on my long term project until I finish central heating and maybe backup after only few times a month. I have other safeguards to monitor the heater including tapo camera pointed at heater.

My point is that all of mine devices works. Reading correct values and activating over distance just fine. I only want function which already exists when activating automation manually to be added to shortcuts as default or option. Thats it.

I'll also add my voice here that humidity and temperature automation with T315 and sockets P110 simply do not work.

For me, two sockets P110, Hub H100, and a sensor T315. They're all in the same room as wifi router and signal's stronger than 50dBm. Actions as simple as "when RH > 60%, then switch ON" are ignored when the threshold is breached, as suggested in main article. 

 I double-checked if automations are turned on (almosting insulting), and created new rules that even pop-up the message that conditions are already met and would be executed. Nothing works. I even tried removing all devices from my Tapo account, readding, resetting everything, and the issue persisted. 

Based on previous comments, it becomes clear to me this is a software issue that needs fixing. It used to work more or less in the past, but recently it became totaly useless.

I'm available for any testing and further information (such as printscreens and whatever)   @Wayne-TP