AC4000 Address Reservation Problem
I have a repeatable problem with Address Reservation on an AC4000 that I am upgrading to from a C5 router. Using the same fifteen IP+MAC addresses used in the C5, Address Reservation and DHCP work fine until I add descriptions to more than one entry. For example, I can add "Amcrest1" to 192.168.1.40, but if I add additional descriptions, DHCP fails completely. I'm not sure which number description causes the failure, but it's somewhere around the fifth. The symptom is no DHCP. My laptop can connect through security to the router but is not given an IP address, and same for my iPhone.
Erasing the descriptions from the IP Reservation entries and rebooting the router usually fixes the problem, but sometimes I'm forced to restore a router-configuration backup that did not have the description entries. If the router backup was made while the IP Reservation descriptions (like "Laptop", "iPhone", "Printer") were present, the router will not work and needs a hard-reset.
Could it be the Address Reservation descriptions, all five of them, take up too much RAM causing DHCP to fail? I just purchased this from Costco on Friday, 2 days ago. Perhaps it defective? I suspect defective firmware since a hard-reset or restored backup will fix it.
Dennis
Edit: It's the second entry in the Address Reservation table. Doesn't matter which entry, the first is tolerated and the second description corrupts DHCP. Erasing all entries (or restoring a backup) restores DHCP operation.
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
Not sure if this really helps, but on the A20, which is quite similar to the C4000, it works fine.
There are some differences between the C4000 and A20, no Printer Server is one on the A20. Different f/w too. C4000 out later and it is V2, while the A20 is V1, both only have the intial f/w.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thank you. That's interesting. The problem is very repeatable on my new A4000; the second description anywhere I've tried kills DHCP every time. My understanding is the A20's hardware is the same, but the firmware is different. I've opened a problem with TP-Link, and hopefully, they fix the firmware, or this is going back.
Dennis
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Before posting, I did a couple of searches on "Address Reservation" but didn't find anything. A few minutes ago, this popped up:
https://community.tp-link.com/us/home/forum/topic/110679
which solved my problem. It is the space character, ASCII 32 Hex 20, causing the problem. "DELL_Laptop" is OK, but "Dell Laptop" kills DHCP. This is a known issue that I wasted too many hours working on.
Thanks,
Dennis
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Not sure if the h/w is the same or not? If the same why 2 different f/w?
Check this thread out, https://community.tp-link.com/us/home/forum/topic/167246
Not a lot of detail there, but other manufactures of other devices change just the model number, HP will change the last 2 digits of the printer depending on where sold.
Since the A20 came out first why create a C4000 that as far as I can tell differs only by 2 features? A20 has Alexa and IFTTT support while the C4000 has a USB Printer Server. I suspect those are all done in firmware, no special h/w?
I have a CostCo membership too, but went with the A20. At the time Amazon had a 20% coupon on it and that made the price difference only a few dollars, and although I could get same day delivery on it, they were out of stock (as were other on-line retailers). My old router was working so I ordered it and it took 10 days to come in. Just checked both places and the A20 now costs $40 more it seems (plus tax).
Why a newer C4000 has a Printer Server and no Alexa or IFTTT support? No clue? If the C4000 still has some problems like the time server and what appears to be a new one with Reserved addresses makes no sense as I'd assume since I've got a V1 and you a V2 that they would have started with the same f/w and made 2 changes that should not have anything to do with Reserved Addresses.
Wonder if you use the MAC and IP Address bonding if you'd have a problem there? That worked well for me too, but the way DHCP hands out IP Address is puzzling to me so I opted for reservations so I know how to reach specific devices.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Den24601 wrote
Before posting, I did a couple of searches on "Address Reservation" but didn't find anything. A few minutes ago, this popped up:
https://community.tp-link.com/us/home/forum/topic/110679
which solved my problem. It is the space character, ASCII 32 Hex 20, causing the problem. "DELL_Laptop" is OK, but "Dell Laptop" kills DHCP. This is a known issue that I wasted too many hours working on.
Thanks,
Dennis
Well, as you can see in my post, I do have a BLANK in the first name...
Interestingly, both the A20 and C4000 are on the first initial f/w.
You are on 1.0.3 Build 20180322 rel.2657, but the A20 is on 1.0.0 Build 20181122 Rel.29339 (5553)? A20 is V1, C4000 V2? C4000 sold before the A20? Based on all this I suspect different h/w and f/w?
Looking at the 2 Data sheets:
C4000 (page 6) https://static.tp-link.com/2017/201712/20171229/Archer%20C4000%20Datasheet%202.0.pdf
A20 (page 8) https://static.tp-link.com/2019/201903/20190319/Archer%20A20(US)1.0_Datasheet.pdf
Note the dates too, the V2 C4000, Dec, 2017, V1 A20, Mar. 2019?
Major differences, the Power Supply:
C4000, External Power Supply: US: 12V/5A , EU: 12V/3.3A
A20, External Power Supply: 12V/4A
A20 is also marked with (US) and it seems to be because of the power supply? US one needs less amperage as well, a sign that at least the internal power distribution chips are different.
Still confused by a V2 product would ship first? Also the slight variation on f/w versions, V1.0.3 vs. V1.0.0?
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Both routers are very similar. The A series you will see on Amazon where the Archer C4000 you will see at retail stores.
Firmware is not the same since they were released at different times.
With respect to the DHCP description issue, please remove any special symbols such as a space or hyphon. Only have letters or numbers.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Tony, seems my A20 can handle 'spaces/blanks' in the name, see screen capture above.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Yes, even one entry, like "Dell Laptop" kills the C4000's DHCP, 100%. "Dell_Laptop" isn't a problem.
It would be great if the installation instructions carried that warning. Better yet, include a warning in the router's embedded instructions.
Dennis
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 0
Views: 1844
Replies: 10
Voters 0
No one has voted for it yet.