Conflicting DHCP when Deco in AP mode ?
Today I ran into an issue which made me almost cringe.. as I hadn't expect this to happen, considering I've been working in the IT networking business for over 30 years..
I had recently purchased a Deco M5 mesh set with 3 nodes and setup as AP access points, because I alread have a decent router from my ISP (Zyxel EMG2926). This has been working fine for the last 6-8 weeks and nothing to complain about.
Last night, for some strange reason my router rebooted and I lost Internet connexion from everywhere, including my wired PC's which I use every day to work from home.. So getting back internet was critical to me and I tried the quick obvious options like rebooting the router and also reseting to factory the router, then reloading the configuration I had on backup.. To no avail, I wasn't able to get an functional internet, still the router diagnostic was able to ping any IP address outside my network.. Since I needed to work and support clients, I disconnected the Zyxel router and put back the Mercku M2 Hive base I had prior to the ISP router and after 5 minutes, was back into business.. (The Mercku is also a Mesh Wi-Fi system with 4 Bee nodes, albeit it wasn't working to my entire satisfaction, thus the purchase of the Deco M5).
Having spend the morning with work, I had hope the issue with the router might have been on the ISP side, so tried to set it back in action. Result was identical and nothing was really working.. Put the Mercku M2 back for the PM as I had a support call and did need internet ASAP.
At the end of the PM I got back to my router and it was so weird that I even tried to reset the Zyxel for the n-th time and start from scratch.. What puzzled me was that it was working if I forced my computer into fixed IP address, and even with DHCP Mac address reservation, the router wouldn't route my requests properly to the internet.. Looking at the IP addresses in the config made me think that router was totaly corrupt and crazy.. The router's IP is 192.168.127.1, but returns 192.168.127.102 as gateway and .254 for the DNS server, which is even crazier.. This is when I started to scan my network for rogue devices with my Android smartphone, but couldn't find anything suspicious. I've a lot of IoT devices and aside of the 3 Deco M5 AP's, there was nothing un-usual. However, the .102 IP address made me tick and look closer at the Mac Address, to finally discover that the main Deco M5 unit (the one connected by Cat5 cable to the switch) was the culprit.
For some obscure reasons my Zyxel router was thinking that the Deco M5 AP unit was the master DHCP on the network, despite TP-Link saying in their documentation that it is not the case when in AP mode.. As a proof, my Mercku M2 router had no issues at all with that and was perfectly handing over IP addresses to all devices..
Has anyone run into such a situation with another HW router ? getting conflicting DHCP server mode while the Deco M5 is in AP mode ?
I fixed my problem my disconnecting the Cat 5 cable temporarly from the switch, rebooted the Zyxel router and voilà.. after it was back as 'master' DHCP, I plugged the Deco M5 back and all was working as before.. But I'm really curious about that strange behavior.
Any comments are welcome on this.
- Copy Link
- Subscribe
- Bookmark
- Report Inappropriate Content
Same here, Deco X20 and this "feature" had me running like a headless chicken for hours, trying to find out what the hell was wrong with my network after my Pihole instance that takes care of both DHCP and DNS crashed...
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi, so far Deco P9 still does not support turning off smart DHCP under access point mode and you are welcome to send an email to support.forum@tp-link.com to tell us:
1.A picture of your network layout.
2. How did you find out Deco P9 started assigning IP addresses?
Thank you very much.
Best regards.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
You're really still doing this???
You've released the ability to disable smart/dumb DHCP on some devices, for good reason as it totally messes us a network but 3.5 years in you're still asking for network diagrams from people for other devices.
Don't you get it yet, it's a terrible feature. Stop wasting the time of your customers and allow it to be disabled on all devices. It should ship disabled by default.
Isn't your product team embarrassed by all this?
David-TP wrote
Hi, so far Deco P9 still does not support turning off smart DHCP under access point mode and you are welcome to send an email to support.forum@tp-link.com to tell us:
1.A picture of your network layout.
2. How did you find out Deco P9 started assigning IP addresses?
Thank you very much.
Best regards.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
I have been having issues around this with an OpenWRT router and a Deco X20. Looks like in my case it was what the response from TPLink says, it seems like openwrt's dnsmasq server for some reason was not responding after detecting another on the network. Noticed there was something about forcing the dhcp server when there are others competing in this doc here https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/base-system/dhcp_configuration#race_conditions_with_netifd
After doing the following in the when sshed into the openwrt, I now seem to have a functioning network
uci set dhcp.lan.force="1" uci commit dhcp /etc/init.d/dnsmasq restart
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@Nemmy Hah, that was it. I guess both devices were being so "smart" that they catch-22ed themselves
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
تضمين التغريدة Hello, I am from Iraq. I work in distributing the Internet through a mikrotik with a hotspot system, broadcasting to mobile phones. A while ago, I bought 10 pieces of the deco s7 router.
When I programmed it with an access point system, the deco distributes the IP address 192.168.68.1 and the feast is from the different IP, and I cannot stop dhcp. I tried a lot and could not. If it is possible to solve this problem, stop dhcp.?? stop I look forward to your response as soon as possible, thank you
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
@TP-Link Hi, please can the feature to switch off the Smart DHCP on the Deco Voice X20 also be added. Or if there is already BETA firmware please share with me I need it urgently.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Sadly I have to laugh in despair. This issue was raised in 2019 and tp-link still can't get their act together to add the option to fully disable "smart DHCP" 4, four, FOUR, FOUR!!! years later.
- Copy Link
- Report Inappropriate Content
Information
Helpful: 8
Views: 46946
Replies: 151